Ten questions for fake news detection
Paper’s reference in the IEEE style?
How did you find the paper?
If applicable, write a list of the search terms you used.
Was the paper peer reviewed? Explain how you found out.
Does the author(s) work in a university or a government-funded research institute? If so, which university or research institute? If not, where do they work?
What does this tell you about their expertise? Are they an expert in the topic area?
What was the paper about?
- Gauge your emotional reaction:
Is it strong? Are you angry? Are you intensely hoping that the information turns out to be true? False?
- Reflect on how you encountered this. Was it promoted on a website? Did it show up in a social media feed? Was it sent to you by
someone you know?
- Consider the headline or main message:
a. Does it use excessive punctuation(!!) or ALL CAPS for emphasis?
b. Does it make a claim about containing a secret or telling you something that “the media” doesn’t want you to know?
c. Don’t stop at the headline! Keep exploring.
- Is this information designed for easy sharing, like a meme?
- Consider the source of the information:
a. Is it a well-known source?
b. Is there a byline (an author’s name) attached to this piece?
c. Go to the website’s “About” section: Does the site describe itself as a “fantasy news” or “satirical news” site?
d. Does the person or organization that produced the information have any editorial standards?
e. Does the “contact us” section include an email address that matches the domain (not a Gmail or Yahoo email address)?
f. Does a quick search for the name of the website raise any suspicions?
- Does the example you’re evaluating have a current date on it?
- Does the example cite a variety of sources, including official and expert sources? Does the information this example provides appear in reports from
(other) news outlets?
- . Does the example hyperlink to other quality sources? In other words, they haven’t been altered or taken from another context?
- Can you confirm, using a reverse image search, that any images in your example are authentic (in other words, sources that haven’t been
altered or taken from another context)?
- If you searched for this example on a fact-checking site such as Snopes.com, FactCheck.org or PolitiFact.com, is there a fact-check that labels it
as less than true?
If applicable, is this paper similar to other papers you have read for this assignment? If so, which papers and why?
If applicable, is this paper different to other papers you have read for this assignment? If so, which papers and why?
What do these similarities and differences suggest? What are your observations? Do you have any new ideas? Do you have any conclusions?
This question is to be answered after your critical analysis is completed: Which sections (if any) of your critical analysis was this paper cited in?